The best acrylic humidor can be a great alternative to a standard wooden humidor for many reasons. While humidors made out of acrylic are not as commonly found as their wooden counterpart, they can provide some benefits that a wooden model cannot, which I’ll go over in this buyer’s guide.
I’ve created this guide for anyone interested in making the switch to acrylic, especially those who have struggled with humidity and calibration issues when using a wooden humidor. I’ve also tested out many of the leading acrylic models on the market and have chosen the top six products that scored well in several areas.
Below, you’ll find a comparison chart that includes each of the must-have acrylic models on the market, their best features, and how they rated.
Acrylic Humidors Comparison Chart
1. Orleans Acrylic Cigar Jar Humidor
This acrylic jar-style humidor uses a traditional clasp closure to secure the top, complete with a rubber gasket seal, promoting an airtight seal. It’s lined with Spanish cedar, just like a traditional wooden humidor and can hold up to twenty-five cigars. Unfortunately, this model doesn’t come with a hygrometer, so you’ll need to purchase one separately. However, it did earn top marks for its clarity and durability, due to the acrylic cell cast materials used.
- Airtight seal
- Holds up to twenty-five cigars
- Lined with Spanish cedar
- Does not come with a hygrometer
This model is durable, lightweight, and made out of thick acrylic that’s very clear, so you can easily monitor the hygrometer’s readings and ensure that the humidor maintains the correct humidity level. The fact that it doesn’t come with a hygrometer may be a drawback for some buyer’s, however, these devices are fairly affordable. Overall, this model is a great buy for the moderate cigar collector, although the serious collector will need to continue looking, in search of a model that has a higher cigar capacity.
2. CigarExtras Acrylic Cigar Humidor
This nine-inch tall humidor is compact and highly portable. It can be used for most types of stogies, even those unique blends that are much taller than an average cigar. This model features a clasp and gasket seal, for an airtight fit that ensures the interior maintains adequate humidity levels in order to keep your cigars smelling and tasting fresh. The inside of the humidor is lined with Spanish cedar, which will extend the life of your cigars. It also has a capacity of twenty-five cigars, which will make it a poor choice for the serious collector. The humidor comes with a humidifier that easily attaches to the underside of the lid, which will leave more space inside the jar for cigar storage.
- Clasp and gasket seal design
- Does not come with a hygrometer
- Low cigar capacity
This model is lacking some important accessories that are often included in wooden humidors, including a hygrometer. However, you can purchase these accessories separately, just make sure the devices you choose are compatible with this model and feature a space-saving design, otherwise you will not be able to fit up to twenty-five cigars inside. The humidor itself is made out of thick, crystal-clear acrylic that’s durable and will not easily crack or chip. This model will be a good buy for anyone in search of a portable humidor or for cigar enthusiasts who do not need to store more than a couple dozen cigars at any given time.
3. Scotte Acrylic Cigar Humidor
This cigar humidor is made of high quality acrylic, has a new style and large capacity. It has a capacity of twenty cigars and you can use it at home or as a travel cigar container. The humidor is designed to maintain an ideal RH level. This premium model comes with a plastic dropper, long strip humidifier, and an alloy stainless steel hygrometer, which is removable. The humidor also features a vintage metal lock and silicone sealing ring, for the best seal possible. Inside, you’ll find Spanish cedar wood pieces which promote a fantastic fragrance and help keep your stogies fresh.
- Silicone sealing ring
- Antique hinges
- Comes with Hygrometer and Humidifier
- Decent price to value ratio
- May scratch easily
- Basic hygrometer
- Lower cigar capacity
This low maintenance humidor is a perfect choice for beginners and veteran cigar connoisseurs. Additionally, the silicone sealing rings, Spanish cedar lining, and circular hygrometer help ensure that your cigars maintain their full flavor and aroma, while the long strip humidifier works to keep constant your optimal range of relative humidity.
4. Prestige Import Group – The Franklin Cigar Humidor
This wooden and acrylic humidor has a cigar capacity of 150 cigars, which is pretty impressive. It also comes with a humidifier, an external mount hygrometer, and a rear door complete with a lock and key. On the rear door, you’ll also find a mirror, which will highlight your cigar collection. Inside, there are a total of two shelves made out of acrylic, with three dividers. The design of the humidor allows you to beautifully display your collection, but it also makes this model a great choice for both home and commercial use. The base and top of the humidor are made out of a rich walnut that features an elegant contrast. While durable, the model itself is very lightweight.
- Includes hygrometer
- High cigar capacity
- Walnut top and base
- Lock and key included
- Does not come with a two-way humidifier
This model allows you to beautifully display your cigar collection and is a great choice whether you need it for home use or your business. The large cigar capacity makes it perfect for the serious collector in need of a model that’s low maintenance. Inside, the six shelves promote excellent air circulation, so you won’t have to bother with rotating the cigars in fear that they will dry out or become over-humidified.
5. Prestige Import Group Roosevelt Humidor
This model has a cigar capacity of 250 cigars and features a lightweight design and three acrylic shelves with dividers that create a total of six shelves. This high capacity model features an upright design that will allow you to professionally display your cigars using a compact design that won’t take up too much table space. The lower section of the humidor can be used to display cigar boxes. This model comes with two humidifiers and one hygrometer. The rear door is equipped with a lock and key to protect your collection.
- Six shelves
- High cigar capacity
- Comes with hygrometer
- Does not include two-way humidifiers so over-humidification is possible
This handsome humidifier comes with plenty of features that the cigar aficionado will appreciate. It’s well-built, durable, made out of thick, crystal clear cell cast acrylic, and includes plenty of space for the serious cigar collector or the cigar shop owner. The biggest drawback is the lack of two-way humidifiers. While this model does come with two humidifiers, they are standard and will continue to produce humidity, which can make it difficult for the user to maintain the correct RH level.
6. Linkidea Cigar Humidor
This durable, lightweight humidor comes with a rubber gasket and clasp design that prevents air and moisture from leaking out. This model has a very low cigar capacity of eighteen cigars. The lightweight design makes this humidor highly portable. It’s made out of thick acrylic material, so it will not crack or chip, even if it’s dropped. This model includes both a humidifier and a hygrometer, so you can keep a close eye on the humidity level and adjust it accordingly.
- Includes hygrometer and humidifier
- Low cigar capacity
This model is made out of tough acrylic material and is highly portable. Considering its low cigar capacity, it’s not a good choice for the serious cigar collector, however, it can still come in handy if you’re planning a trip and need a humidor that’s highly portable and durable.
Acrylic Humidors Buyer’s Guide
An acrylic humidor can be a great low-maintenance storage solution for premium cigars. They are the modern alternative to the best cigar humidors that many cigar smokers are familiar with, and they’re much flashier than their wooden counterparts.
Unfortunately, you won’t find many of these models on the market since wooden humidors are more popular. However, thanks to some of the best humidor brands, I’m confident that you’ll soon notice a trend, as more and more bigger players in the industry release their own special acrylic models.
Some types of humidors are also made out of glass, however, many have found these humidors to be too heavy and fragile, making acrylic a much better alternative.
Benefits of Acrylic Humidors
While some experienced cigar enthusiasts can argue that wood is a much better choice for cigar storage, acrylic models offer many benefits, such as:
- Acrylic is much lighter than wood and glass
- Glass humidors are also a popular option and are often chosen because of their more elegant design, however, models that are made out of this material are much heavier and more fragile.
- Acrylic is very durable. Additionally, acrylic contains additives that will prevent degradation when exposed to UV light. This means it has significantly better UV absorbing properties.
- Not only are acrylic models very decorative, but they are also available in a variety of sizes, styles, and shapes.
- These storage devices will provide an airtight seal. Acrylic consists of a non-porous material that will not absorb moisture, so you will not have to season the humidor prior to using it like you do with wooden models.
- These humidors are much lighter compared to other cigar storage solutions.
- Acrylic is very durable. Plastic will turn yellow as it ages and will become brittle, cracking over time. Acrylic is a type of material that’s very hard-wearing.
- This material is also transparent. This will make it easier for you to check the hygrometer’s settings without opening the humidor and disturbing the perfect balance of the micro-climate inside.
- Because of the lightweight design, these models are also highly portable and can be a better option to use when you’re flying or planning a road trip.
Other Important Features
As you can see, this type of humidor offers many benefits that a standard wooden humidor doesn’t. Now, I’ll go over the important features to look for that can help you choose a great model for your cigar collection.
Design: Jars and Boxes
Many of these humidors will come in either a jar design or a box design that’s similar to a traditional wooden humidor. The jar models are made to hold a smaller number of cigars, while the larger box style humidors can hold anywhere from twenty cigars up to three hundred. The jar humidors feature a unique design, with the humidifier usually installed under the lid. Most types of jar style models will feature a clasp and rubber gasket design that provides an excellent airtight seal, although they may need to be replaced more often than a traditional humidor since the rubber gasket tends to wear out rather quickly, especially if you open your humidor often. The biggest benefit of this type of humidor is that it’s highly portable and durable, so it can be a great option if you’re searching for a humidor for vacation or car use. They’re also the most affordable option, so they’re a great choice for the cigar enthusiast on a budget. If you’re new to cigar collecting, it can also be a great choice, due to the low cigar capacity.
Some of the smaller capacity boxes are designed to be disposable. Many manufacturers will guarantee these boxes for a determined period of time, such as six to twelve months before they should be tossed out and replaced. These small boxes are often priced affordably and don’t require any maintenance. Larger models will have a lifespan similar to that of a traditional wooden humidor and can last for years with proper care. Often, these models are still priced more affordably compared to wooden humidors.
With any type of humidor, the seal is everything. A truly airtight seal will keep your cigars smelling and tasting fresh. The quality of the seal will depend heavily on how well the opening closes. Look for a model that features a magnetic locking system, which makes a humidor easy to open and provides an excellent seal. Most models will come equipped with a mechanical or rubber seal, both of which can work well, but a magnetic locking system is by far the best option. If the humidor has a low-quality seal it will be difficult to adjust the humidity.
One issue you may encounter with lower priced humidors made out of acrylic is the chemical smell. This is a common problem, but one you can easily resolve by allowing the humidor to remain open to air out for a period of twenty-four hours, after which point the smell will dissipate.
Many people turn to acrylic humidors because of the material’s ability to absorb UV light. This will allow you to take a peek at the hygrometer and ensure the micro-climate is on point, all without opening the lid. While these humidors have a reputation for their ability to block harmful UV rays, they are not able to filter it out entirely. Because of this, you should still avoid placing the humidor in direct sunlight. Sunlight can potentially discolor your cigars and can cause a greenhouse effect in which the interior will heat up. The humidor can also be susceptible to fluctuating humidity levels since some lower quality acrylic humidors do not have the best insulation. If a model that struggles to maintain the right humidity level is placed in direct sunlight, it can have an impact on the scent and flavor of the cigar.
A high-quality humidor should have joints that are properly fused or well-glued if a particular model is made out of several parts. If the humidor has been injection molded, then weak joints will not be a concern. However, a model that has weak points may have gaps in the design that can allow moisture to escape, so paying close attention to the quality of the design and the humidor’s durability will be important.
Types of Acrylic
Thick, high quality acrylic will ensure that the humidor is durable and able to maintain the correct micro-climate. Unfortunately, not all acrylic is created equal.
This type of acrylic is weak and cheap. It contains impurities and is softer and often found on low-priced models. It also has a tendency to scratch and can easily crack if dropped.
Cell cast acrylic is used in high-priced humidors and is much clearer and thicker than continuous cast acrylic.
If you’re not sure what type of acrylic the humidor is made out of, look at the weight and read reviews regarding durability. High-quality acrylic will be heavier than continuous cast.
Unlike a wooden humidor, an acrylic model is much easier to maintain. However, as I mentioned earlier, some models will have a strong chemical smell, right out of the box. Fortunately, this is an easy fix and simply requires you to leave the humidor out and wide open until the smell has dissipated. This should take no more than a few hours, but many experts recommend allowing the humidor to air out for a period of twenty-four hours.
Another possible problem is over-humidification. Because many of the leading models are airtight, it can be easy to over-humidify the interior. This means you will need to be extra careful with the type of humidifier you use. Most humidifiers will come with a basic one-way humidification system. These types of humidifiers will continue to release moisture, even when the humidor has achieved the perfect RH level. A two-way humidification system will cease to release moisture once the humidor’s humidity level has reached the ideal level. Two-way systems also work to absorb any excess moisture, which makes them a perfect choice for a model made out of acrylic.
Using humidifier packs, such as Boveda humidity packs, can be a great choice since they don’t need to be recharged and are self-maintaining. They also offer two-way humidity control. These packs will take up very little space, so they are also a great choice for a smaller humidor.
The cost of an acrylic humidor will depend on the type of acrylic used, the size and cigar capacity, and the type of accessories included. High-priced models are designed to hold one to three hundred cigars, whereas small, portable models can hold ten to thirty cigars. Obviously, the serious cigar collector will want to go bigger, but they should also expect to pay a higher price.
If you’re looking for a low-maintenance solution and an alternative to a standard wooden humidor, then an acrylic model is the perfect choice, although you’ll find that the selection is pretty limited compared to wooden humidors.
The best acrylic cigar humidor will be made out of cell cast acrylic and will come with an airtight seal that will make it much easier for the humidor to maintain the perfect micro-climate. The models that I’ve included here in my guide each earned top marks for their overall quality, top-notch construction, seal design, and their durability.
I hope this guide and my product recommendations has helped you choose a model that will work perfectly for your cigar collection, future smoking needs, and your budget. As always…Happy Puffing!